Just Grade, Please.

Turning college into a zero-sum game hurts their chances of succeeding after graduation.

Source: Why We Should Stop Grading Students on a Curve

Here’s my take.

I’m a former math professor. From my experience, all of this fuss about grading is really a fuss about how students “feel”; that is, how they feel about their “college experience”. Administrators don’t want anything to effect that experience negatively. That would lead to lower US News rankings.

It’s not that student feelings aren’t important. They are very important. But I have found that when a professor treats his/her students with concern, care, and respect, then the professor can get on with his/her job – seeing that the students learn. After all, learning is, in the long run, what professors can contribute to students’ feelings.

Now for grading. That’s easy. When I teach a course, I have a really good idea of what learning the material “excellently”, “well”, “average”, etc…means and I grade accordingly; and my students know that. It’s that simple to be a good professor. To be a good employee (from the perspective of an administration that cares for its own “feelings”) is not so easy. To see that, see my blog inside-higher-ed .

The US productivity puzzle – This Financial Times’ Article Implies That Most Economists Miss a Critical Factor

The dramatic slide in US productivity will be one of the defining features of the next president’s economic inheritance. Yet when it comes to diagnosing the causes of the slowdown, or coming up with cures, there is little consensus among … [Continue reading]

You Sure You Got That?

And now for a little humour. This is from a book by one of the most famous fly fishermen of all time. You don't have to know anything about fishing; just pay attention to the math. "...to know what...size tippet to use, divide the size of the … [Continue reading]

What Does the Graph Reveal?

In a novel experiment, the Education Department announced Tuesday up to $17 million in loans and grants for students to undergo training at eight entities that aren’t traditional colleges. Source: Obama Administration to Fund Nontraditional Training … [Continue reading]

Is a Ph.D. Holder a Qualified Ph.D.? Not Always

As the supply of doctorate holders grows and their academic job prospects dwindle, schools take steps to help graduates find work beyond the academy. Source: Job-Seeking Ph.D. Holders Look to Life Outside School My comment. Advice from a retired … [Continue reading]

Frank Bruni Recognizes the “Customer” Mentality

"...It’s not only at Stanford and at Ivy League and Ivy­like schools that students have gone from being competitors to clients. That’s a shift that’s occurred over recent decades and over the last decade in particular at scores if not hundreds of … [Continue reading]

What Does the Syllabus Really Tell You? And How to Find Out What is Really Taught.

A reader looked at this year's syllabus for the course that I wrote about in A Tale Out of School. The reader commented that there was nothing wrong with what this year's syllabus covers.  Let's look deeper and ask what covers means. For those who … [Continue reading]

A Quote to Keep in Mind

"...Franklin Roosevelt did not suddenly decide on his own to enact Social Security or grant union rights. Those ideas came up from below, through decades of frustration and struggle and conflict. If Americans want something different from their … [Continue reading]

Let’s Stop Worrying About the Wrong Problem (Dropping Out) and Address the Real Problem (Not Getting An Education Even IF They Stay In)

Simple steps raise the graduation rate, especially among minority students. Source: What Can Stop Kids From Dropping Out - The New York Times#commentsContainer I wrote: Let's stop worrying about them dropping out and start worrying about them … [Continue reading]