David Brooks See the Symptom – But Not the Disease

Source: Mis-Educating the Young – The New York Times

Here is my comment.

You have described the symptoms well, but you have missed the disease.

The disease is letting higher education operate as a market economy – while assuming that, as a non-profit, it is altruistic. Just listen to Clark Kerr and David Riesman on what that leads to.

“…This shift from academic merit to student consumerism is one of the two greatest reversals of direction in all the history of American higher education..” (Clark Kerr, in Riesman’s book, cited below)

“…the “wants” of students…are quite different from the “needs” of students…advantage can..be taken…by unscrupulous instructors and institutions…” (David Riesman, from his 1980 book, On Higher Education: The Academic Enterprise in an Era of Rising Student Consumerism)

These two eminent sociologists warned us, but we didn’t listen. And now, 30+ years later, the overwhelming majority of graduates, though degreed, are not educated – no fault of their own.

And not getting a job is not the worst of it for society.

Most high school teachers don’t really get a college education. So how can we expect skilled high school graduates?

Even a large number of “professors” are produced to fill jobs at many regional state schools Their students, many of them future high school teachers, don’t have a chance.

To see the stories from what I have described, read some of the tales from higher education that you can find on my blog inside-higher-ed .

All of this must stop before it is too late.

Take on the 800-lb Gorilla

Source: US workforce: paying young Americans to learn the right skills I made the following comment. Someone has to take on the 800 lb gorilla.  I have seen it in action up close and Bill Gross has pointed out that it really is an 800 lb … [Continue reading]

“America’s Broken Democracy” by Jeffrey D. Sachs Misses the Main Point: Money Can’t Trick Education, at Least Not So Easily

Source: America’s Broken Democracy by Jeffrey D. Sachs - Project Syndicate Here is the comment that I posted. Thomas Jefferson saw clearly how to prevent the system being overcome by what he called "kings, priests and nobles". Here is what he … [Continue reading]

Cheating and “Retention”

This story ran in the NY Times: As Computer Coding Classes Swell So Does Cheating . I began to wonder if a general concern for actual "education" - at least in courses where major corporations would care - was making an appearance again. I … [Continue reading]

Colleges Resist Federal Effort to Gauge Student Outcomes – WSJ

Source: Colleges Resist Federal Effort to Gauge Student Outcomes - WSJ Nothing new here to readers of this blog I wrote, Of course they don't want anyone to know.  Want to see the smelly reason why? Just read "A Tale Out of School" (on my … [Continue reading]

Loans ‘Designed to Fail’ No, Simply Designed to Make Money, Not Educate

Source: Loans ‘Designed to Fail’: States Say Navient Preyed on Students - The New York Times I wrote, I taught at a "non-profit" (Why they are called that, I have no idea.) "elite" university. As an insider, here is my advice for readers. I … [Continue reading]

“Evidence That Robots Are Winning the Race for American Jobs” (NYT) But Here is Why, and They Shouldn’t

Source: Evidence That Robots Are Winning the Race for American Jobs - The New York Times I wrote why, at least in my opinion> The keyword is “SKILLS”, as in “If you worked in Detroit for 10 years, you don’t have the skills to go into health … [Continue reading]

“Why Singapore’s kids are so good at maths” – and the US Isn’t

Source: Why Singapore’s kids are so good at maths Here is a highlighted quote from the article. Mathematics in Singapore is not about knowing everything. It’s about thinking like a mathematician Andreas Schleicher, head of the OECD’s education … [Continue reading]

NYT “Years of Ethics Charges, but Star Cancer Researcher Gets a Pass”Larger Questions? You Bet!

Source: Years of Ethics Charges, but Star Cancer Researcher Gets a Pass - The New York Times I wrote: Here is the "..Large Question.." and its Obvious Answer. (Even though I'm a professor, please don't sleep through this.) Larger Question: … [Continue reading]