Research Indicates Even Top Departments Calling A No-Go For a PhD, a Guess What? A PhD!

Here is a link to the paper.  (I will make my point after quoting from the paper.) JEP (28,3) p. 205 – The Research Productivity of New PhDs in Economics: The Surprisingly High Non-success of the Successful. Here is an important conclusion quoted from the paper. “…At the majority of the departments ranked in the top […]

Are High School Students – And Their Parents – Misled About Their Math Knowledge? Probably.

I just read an online discussion by high school students.  They were wondering how today’s math courses compare to the ones in the 60’s. I attended high school in the sixties and took the most advanced course that my East Texas town of 35,000 had to offer; and, of course, I grew up with people from that era, so […]

Teaching Effectiveness is NEGATIVELY Associated With Student Evaluations

That is a partial quote from an important new paper by Philip B. Stark and Richard Freishtat.  Here is a more complete version of the quote. These experiments found that teaching effectiveness, as measured by subsequent performance and career success, is negatively associated with [student evaluations]. (from page 12) This paper is important – especially for parents […]

Blatant plagiarism sinks paper (and earns a sabbatical!) for mathematician From “Retraction Watch”

Blatant plagiarism sinks paper (and earns a sabbatical!) for mathematician | Retraction Watch. This is timely since I’m in the process of writing about “paper rustling“. I will make one comment about the story from Retraction Watch. The case described there is petty only in the sense that it doesn’t make or break big careers.  […]

I Have Started “The Purloined Proof”

The (true) tale will have it’s own page, The Purloined Proof.

Academic Integrity in Research? Not Always.

Someone asked me about research integrity.  Here was my answer.  (It was posted here: http://online.wsj.com/articles/a-bit-of-college-can-be-worse-than-none-at-all-1413158511?KEYWORDS=college#livefyre-comment ) ” I don’t want to comment on anything other than academic integrity, but that I can do.  First, here is a quote.   “…the ethical standards of the sciences ( certainly in mathematics) have been degraded to such an […]

Piketty’s “Key to Overall Productivity Growth” and “the Reduction of Inequality”

The following are quotes from Thomas Piketty’s seminal Capital in the Twenty-First Century.  I have used italics to emphasize parts that I think are particularly important with respect to education. “…Knowledge and skill diffusion is the key to overall productivity growth as well as the reduction of inequality…” (p. 21) “…Do the dynamics of private […]

Arum and Roksa’s Important New Book “Aspiring Adults Adrift”

I just got my copy.  As I read it, I will post comments under the category “Comments on ‘Aspiring Adults Adrift’”. If you haven’t read their critically important first book “Academically Adrift”, I highly recommend it.  In previous posts, I have used some of the material from that book.  For now, I will repeat a couple of […]

Reminder and Notice

When I first posted A Tale Out of School, along with the highly revealing emails from administrators and others, it got a lot of hits. I’m posting this “reminder and notice” for new visitors who may not be aware of the article  and want to read it – or even read just the accompanying emails. I think […]