Not Being Good at Math – Should That Be a Bar to Getting a PhD in Math?

Many years ago, my wife and I were at a volleyball tournament.  We were fortunate to sit next to a high school (or maybe middle school) volleyball coach.  He was big, friendly and knowledgeable.  Let’s call him Jack. Jack told us that he was a math teacher.  As I recall, he said he went to […]

The Economist Cover Story “How Science Goes Wrong” and NY Times “Risk Calculator for Cholesterol Appears Flawed”; Connected?

Both of these stories focus on what could be a failure of professionals to understand and utilize quantitative data and methods.  In the case of the cholesterol test, I have no way of knowing exactly how the failure occured.  But I am worried that it is symptomatic of our problems in higher education.  I posted […]

More on The Atlantic’s Article on Teaching Math

(The article is here http://www.theatlantic.com/education/archive/2013/11/the-stereotypes-about-math-that-hold-americans-back/281303/#disqus_thread ) There were some interesting replies to my comment on the article.  I am posting my response to this one because it might be informative for some readers of this blog.  It states my view, and probably the view of many others, of two of the problems facing professors now.  The […]

Excellent Explanation of How to Teach Math in The Atlantic – But…

…as I commented on the site, where do we get the teachers?  (The article, which I recommend is at http://www.theatlantic.com/education/archive/2013/11/the-stereotypes-about-math-that-hold-americans-back/281303/#disqus_thread) “I am a former math professor. I totally agree with the author about how math can best be learned.  There is a gigantic hurdle: where do we get the people (teachers) who themselves were taught […]

Addendum to “Peter Cappeli” Post – Another Testimony About Higher Ed

Dan Laroque put this comment on the WSJ “… In the latter years of my teaching career, it got very frustrated dealing with students and administration. The universities have literally turned the curriculum standards over to the students. It is all about garnering as many students in a major as possible with no rules on rigor. It is ‘take […]

Another Good Article by Miles Kimball & Noah Smith on Learning Math

The authors wrote a previous article for The Atlantic that explains the need for math in economics.   Here is a link to a post on that article  Need for Math to Study Econ – Excellent Description – But… They have now written their suggestions on changing how math is taught.  The article makes a good point […]

How Can Frank Bruni Be Excited About Change in K-12 Without Change in Higher Ed?

Change in K-12 does matter but I don’t see how it can help a lot without the change in higher ed that I advocate here.  Here is a link to his op-ed, followed by my comment. http://www.nytimes.com/2013/10/29/opinion/bruni-a-bold-bid-for-better-schools.html?ref=opinion&comments&_r=0 ” From whence cometh these teachers?  They cometh from the universities, many of whom seek fame and fortune […]

Machiavelli on How to Keep Control of a University

I am reading “The Prince” (I would say rereading but it has been so long since I first read it, I don’t think I get to call it “rereading”.) and I came across this quote that I think applies to today’s universities: “…he who would keep a city accustomed to freedom will hold it more […]

New Page Added

In my previous post, Time Magazine Writes That Americans Have Feelings About Online Education?, I questioned why Americans would think they have informed views on MOOC’s when so many colleges grads know so little.  (See the post for how little, “so little” is.) But then, I could say that about many topics, not just MOOC’s.  […]